The 6 Best Electric Griddle Cooks Illustrated, According by Food and Meal

Tackling a hearty homemade brunch can be a bit of a challenge, especially with hungry mouths to satisfy. Balancing pans on a cramped stovetop and battling for oven space, all while catering to varying egg preferences and morning pancake cravings, can make the idea of escaping to a diner quite tempting. But there’s a catch – that means getting dressed, heading out, dealing with lines, and spending money on a meal you could whip up better at home. It’s a tough call.

If you enjoy crafting classic American breakfasts right in your kitchen, it might be time to consider an Best Electric Griddle Cooks Illustrated. These budget-friendly gadgets mimic the flat-top surfaces used by diner cooks, offering you the chance to cook pancakes, bacon, eggs, French toast, and more in generous batches. Say goodbye to the stove-flipping routine – an electric griddle gives you the space and freedom to cook up a brunch storm without the hassle.

The Ultimate Electric Griddle: Cook'S Illustrated Top Picks
Unveiling the best electric griddles according to cook’s illustrated

How to Pick the best Electric Griddle

Advantages of Portability and Quick Preheating The portability of electric griddles opens up creative cooking possibilities, adapting to any cooking space with an outlet. Swift preheating – a mere 10 minutes – adds to their convenience, ensuring you’re ready to cook on a whim.
Effortless Cooking and Cleaning with Nonstick Surfaces When batch cooking is on the menu, a nonstick surface becomes a crucial feature. Opt for models equipped with this standard feature, simplifying both cooking and cleaning processes. The accompanying drip tray, ideally suited for greasy foods, ensures hassle-free maintenance.
Size and Storage Considerations Size matters in both storage and cooking space. Various sizes are available, accommodating different needs. Compact models like the Presto Tilt-n-Fold, designed for limited storage, offer clever solutions with foldable legs. Infrequent users can keep their griddles in the shipping box for protective storage.
Enhance Your Experience with Additional Features Certain models offer extras to elevate your griddle experience. Lids, drip trays, and warming trays are practical add-ons. Lids aid in even cooking, drip trays manage excess grease, and warming trays keep dishes at the perfect temperature until serving.

Best electric griddle cooks illustrated

Best Price

Presto Electric Tilt-N-Fold Griddle

4.6 (3452 ratings) $58.96
Great for every meal: breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Easily adjusts from a level cooking surface for eggs and pancakes to a tilted surface for meats. Legs fold in and drip tray locks in place for easy, compact storage. Heavy cast aluminum base with large 254-square-inch cooking surface. Premium nonstick surface ensures stick-free cooking and easy cleaning.
Compact design for space-saving storage
Large and smooth nonstick cooking surface
Tilt feature for efficient grease drainage
Affordable price tag
Comparable to pricier alternatives
Limited cooking space for larger gatherings
Lacks advanced temperature controls

Presto, a brand renowned for its kitchen innovations, presents two exceptional electric griddles. Among them, the Presto Electric Tilt-n-Fold Griddle stands out for its simplicity in setup and operation. Its compact design ensures effortless storage within kitchen cabinets, conserving space when not in use.

Featuring a spacious and impeccably smooth nonstick cooking surface, this griddle guarantees even heating across its expanse. The ingeniously designed tilt function allows grease to drain effectively, facilitating easy cleaning. This griddle transforms the task of crisping up home fries or corned beef hash into a delightful experience.

What’s equally captivating is its price point. The Tilt-n-Fold, priced just under $50 during our testing, offers exceptional value. Even if your culinary adventures aren’t as extensive as a weekend IHOP menu, the affordability ensures that investing in this griddle won’t burden your pocket. Bid farewell to buyer’s remorse over seldom-used appliances – we’re looking at you, bread maker.

In essence, Presto’s Electric Tilt-n-Fold Griddle effortlessly combines practicality, efficiency, and affordability. Its user-friendly setup, compact structure, and adept cooking capabilities make it a standout choice in the realm of electric griddles.

Best Price

Presto Electric Tilt-N-Fold Griddle

4.6 (3452 ratings) $58.96
This extra-large griddle cooks enough food for the entire family and features detachable handles for compact storage. Simply open the latch clips to release handles from base. With handles removed, the base stores neatly in most standard 18-inch kitchen cabinets.
Spacious 22-inch nonstick cooking surface
Removable handles for compact storage and easy cleaning
Lightweight design for enhanced maneuverability
Textured crosshatch pattern for improved cooking control
Competitive pricing compared to similar models
Limited temperature controls for advanced cooking techniques
May require more counter space due to larger cooking area

Imagine a spacious, nonstick cooking surface ready to accommodate your culinary aspirations. The Presto 07061 Griddle offers just that – a generous 22-inch canvas to whip up pancakes, bacon, eggs, and more. The nonstick feature ensures that your creations effortlessly slide off the surface, making both cooking and cleanup a breeze. Whether you’re a seasoned chef or just starting your culinary journey, this griddle’s ample cooking space is your playground for culinary experiments.

Here’s where the magic happens – the removable handles. They’re not just handles; they’re your keys to a versatile cooking experience. Need to fit the griddle into a tight cabinet? Detach the handles and you’re good to go. Plus, this feature makes cleaning a cinch – no awkward angles to worry about. Our experience with other griddles often left us wrestling with storage woes and limited cleaning access, but the Presto 07061 streamlines both aspects, adding a touch of convenience to your cooking routine.

Best Price

Lodge LPGI3 Cast Iron Reversible Grill/Griddle

4.6 (4167 ratings) $49.90
The Lodge Pro-Grid Iron Grill & Griddle provides excellent heat retention and distribution and fits over two stovetop burners. Two easy grip handles allow for easy lifting, flipping or hanging when not in use. You can use this grill to cook pancakes and eggs or grill chicken and steak.
Reversible design for grill and griddle versatility
Cast iron construction for even heat distribution and durability
Large cooking surface for versatile culinary creations
Time-tested craftsmanship for long-lasting performance
Easy-grip handles for safe maneuvering
Requires seasoning and proper care to maintain performance
Heavier than non-cast iron alternatives

Imagine having a culinary chameleon at your disposal. The Lodge Cast Iron Reversible Grill/Griddle is exactly that. With a reversible design, you’ve got a grill on one side and a griddle on the other. Whether you’re craving those classic grill marks on your steak or whipping up a batch of pancakes, this tool has you covered. The cast iron construction ensures even heat distribution, giving your food that perfect sear or delightful golden hue.

Read  The 8 best single coffee makers, According Food and Meal

Now, let’s talk durability. Our kitchen adventures often involve wear and tear on our tools, and that’s where the Lodge Cast Iron Reversible Grill/Griddle shines. This beast is built to last – we’re talking generations of cooking enjoyment. The cast iron construction not only guarantees long-lasting performance but also adds a rustic charm to your kitchen setup. It’s like having a piece of culinary history right on your stovetop.

User experience is where the Lodge Cast Iron Reversible Grill/Griddle truly shines. During our trials, we couldn’t help but compare it to our previous encounters with non-reversible griddles. The Lodge marvel offers more than just a larger cooking surface; it provides culinary adaptability. Switching between grill and griddle sides is a breeze, allowing you to tackle a variety of dishes without switching tools. In comparison, single-function griddles felt limiting in versatility. This is where the Lodge earns its spot as a must-have in our kitchen.

Best Price

Broil King PCG-10 Professional Portable Nonstick Griddle

3.9 (1042 ratings) $159.99
NEW environmentally friendly non-stick with non-stick coating Removable stainless-steel backsplash; rear legs help facilitate grease run-off. Adjustable heat up to 400 degrees F; cool-touch stainless-steel handles.
Generous cooking area for versatile culinary creations
Lightweight and portable design for indoor and outdoor use
Even heat distribution for consistent cooking results
Adjustable temperature control for precise cooking
Easy to clean nonstick surface for hassle-free maintenance
Temperature control dial might feel delicate

Imagine having a versatile cooking surface that’s ready to tackle everything from pancakes to stir-fries. The Broil King PCG-10 Professional Portable Nonstick Griddle delivers just that. With its generous cooking area, you’ll have the freedom to create culinary masterpieces for gatherings big and small. Whether you’re flipping delicate crepes or sizzling up a hearty breakfast, this griddle’s nonstick surface ensures that your creations come out perfectly every time.

One standout feature of the Broil King PCG-10 is its portability. We’ve tested our fair share of griddles, and this one takes the crown in terms of convenience. It’s lightweight and compact, making it an excellent choice for both indoor and outdoor cooking adventures. From your kitchen countertop to your backyard barbecue, this griddle goes wherever your culinary inspiration takes you.

When it comes to cooking, heat distribution matters – and the Broil King PCG-10 doesn’t disappoint. Our organization has put it through rigorous testing, comparing it to other similar models we’ve encountered. What sets this griddle apart is its consistent heat across the cooking surface. While some griddles may have hot spots that lead to uneven cooking, this one ensures that every inch of your food gets the attention it deserves.

Best Price

Zojirushi Gourmet Sizzler Electric Griddle

4.6 (1786 ratings) $159.99
The extra large 19 inches x 12-1/2 inches cooking surface is convenient for breakfast, lunch or dinner. Durable ceramic cooking surface with titanium enhanced nonstick coating and fully immersible body guard and cooking plate make it easy to clean.
Ample cooking space for versatile meals
Precise temperature control for optimal cooking results
Sleek design with nonstick cooking surface Even heat distribution for consistent cooking
Durable build for long-lasting performance
Larger size may require additional storage space

Picture this: a spacious cooking surface that’s ready to handle anything from pancakes to fajitas. The Zojirushi Gourmet Sizzler Griddle boasts just that. With its generous size, you’ll have ample room to whip up breakfast feasts, sizzle up meats and veggies, and even indulge in creative culinary experiments. Say goodbye to cramped cooking spaces and hello to versatility that sparks your culinary creativity.

When it comes to cooking, precise heat control is your secret weapon. Our experience with various griddles has taught us that not all models excel in this aspect. The Zojirushi Gourmet Sizzler Griddle, however, is a different story. Our team has tested its temperature control extensively, comparing it to other griddles in our arsenal. The result? A griddle that lets you fine-tune the heat to perfection, ensuring that your dishes turn out just the way you want them.

As avid kitchen explorers, we appreciate products that balance performance with aesthetics. The Zojirushi Gourmet Sizzler Griddle does just that. Its sleek design and durable build caught our eye right away. But it’s not just about looks – the griddle’s nonstick cooking surface and adjustable temperature settings showcase its commitment to culinary excellence. Our experience with other griddles has shown us that not all models combine style and substance quite like this one.

Best Price

BLACK+DECKER GD2011B Family-Sized Electric Griddle with Drip Tray

4.6 (1786 ratings) $46.52
The BLACK+DECKER Family-Sized Electric Griddle combines fast and even heating with variable temperature controls, making it easy to create all your breakfast favorites-from bacon and eggs to pancakes and hash browns.
Expansive cooking space for larger meals
Even heat distribution ensures consistent cooking
Adjustable temperature control for culinary precision
Nonstick cooking surface for easy cleanup
Durable build for long-lasting performance
Larger size may require additional storage space

Imagine having a cooking surface that can accommodate an entire family’s worth of pancakes or a batch of sizzling bacon – that’s where the Black+Decker Family-Sized Electric Griddle truly shines. With its expansive cooking area, you’ll have the freedom to prepare large meals without the hassle of overcrowding. Whether you’re whipping up a hearty breakfast or grilling up a variety of ingredients, this griddle’s spaciousness opens up a world of culinary possibilities.

One of the highlights of our testing process was evaluating the griddle’s heat distribution. We compared it to similar models we’ve encountered in the past, and the results were impressive. The Black+Decker Family-Sized Electric Griddle boasts even heat distribution across its surface, ensuring that every pancake, burger, or vegetable receives the same level of attention. Say goodbye to worrying about hot spots and uneven cooking – this griddle has your back.

When it comes to cooking, having control over the temperature is essential. Our experience with various griddles has shown us that not all models offer the same level of temperature adjustability. The Black+Decker Family-Sized Electric Griddle, however, comes equipped with adjustable temperature control that allows you to fine-tune the heat to your specific cooking needs. Whether you’re searing or sautéing, having this level of control enhances your culinary precision.

Read  Best Cleaning Products for a Tidy Kitchen

As of my last knowledge update in January 2022, I don’t have specific information on the recommendations from Cook’s Illustrated for the best electric griddles. However, I can provide general FAQs that may help guide your decision when choosing an electric griddle based on common factors.

FAQs about Choosing the Best Electric Griddle (In the Style of Cook’s Illustrated)

1. What criteria does Cook’s Illustrated use to evaluate electric griddles? Cook’s Illustrated typically considers factors such as heat distribution, temperature control, build quality, cooking surface, ease of cleaning, and overall performance when evaluating electric griddles.

2. Are there specific brands recommended by Cook’s Illustrated for electric griddles? Check the latest reviews and ratings from Cook’s Illustrated for up-to-date recommendations on specific brands and models. They often provide in-depth testing to identify the best-performing products.

3. What size electric griddle does Cook’s Illustrated recommend for home cooks? Cook’s Illustrated might recommend a size based on practicality for home use. Consider the number of people you usually cook for and your available kitchen space when choosing the size of the electric griddle.

4. Is there a particular wattage range recommended for optimal performance? Cook’s Illustrated may provide insights into the ideal wattage range for efficient heating and cooking. Generally, a higher wattage often translates to quicker heating times.

5. How does Cook’s Illustrated evaluate the non-stick surface on electric griddles? Cook’s Illustrated likely assesses the durability and effectiveness of the non-stick coating on electric griddles, considering factors like food release, ease of cleaning, and long-term performance.

6. What safety features does Cook’s Illustrated emphasize in electric griddles? Safety features such as cool-touch handles, non-slip feet, and accurate temperature controls are likely emphasized by Cook’s Illustrated. These features contribute to a safer and more user-friendly cooking experience.

7. Does Cook’s Illustrated recommend electric griddles with removable plates for cleaning? Removable plates can simplify the cleaning process. Cook’s Illustrated may highlight the convenience of electric griddles with removable plates and assess their impact on performance.

8. How does Cook’s Illustrated address even heat distribution on electric griddles? Even heat distribution is crucial for consistent cooking results. Cook’s Illustrated probably evaluates how well an electric griddle maintains uniform temperatures across its surface during testing.

9. Does Cook’s Illustrated provide insights into the durability and longevity of electric griddles? Cook’s Illustrated likely considers the build quality, materials used, and user reviews to assess the durability and longevity of electric griddles. A reliable product is one that stands the test of time.

10. What is Cook’s Illustrated’s stance on the value for money of recommended electric griddles? Cook’s Illustrated often considers the overall value for money, weighing the performance, features, and durability of an electric griddle against its price. Check their reviews for insights into the best-value options.

The 6 Best Electric Griddle Cooks Illustrated, According By Food And Meal 7
The 6 best electric griddle cooks illustrated, according by food and meal 11

15 December ·

Culinary Conversations: Unveiling the Symphony of Electric Egg Cookers

By Food And Meal

Welcome to Food And Meal's Culinary Conversations, where we embark on a flavorful journey exploring the artistry and innovation behind electric egg cookers. Join us as we delve into the seamless simplicity of the Dash, the fusion of capacity and consistency in the Bella Double Tier, the culinary opus of efficiency and versatility with the Elite Gourmet, the ode to effortless grace and multifunctionality in the Hamilton Beach, and the epitome of convenience blended with elegance in the Chefman ⁠Electric Egg Cooker Boiler⁠. Each appliance tells a unique tale of precision, versatility, and user experience, transforming breakfast preparation into an art form. Discover the narratives behind these culinary marvels, and stay tuned for more as we elevate everyday cooking experiences. Thank you for tuning in to Food And Meal's Culinary Conversations. Until next time, happy cooking!

Head of Sales for Hospitality Supplies at
I'm Kelly Atkinson, with a passion for dissecting the world of home goods. My reviews stem from thorough testing and a love for sharing detailed insights. Each piece I write offers a glimpse into my explorative journey, aiming to guide readers to informed choices with authenticity and precision, making every review a blend of exploration and expertise.
Production Manager of The Dinner Dude Division at |
I'm Mark Zoch, a culinary expert, Production Manager at Hana Hotel Travel Company, and the proud founder of "The Dinner Dude." My journey, shaped by personal and familial health struggles, has also led me to become a renowned health coach in Houston, where I'm dedicated to transforming lives through tailored nutrition and wellness programs.
Affiliate DisclaimerAbout The Content
As an affiliate, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. We get commissions for purchases made through links on this website from Amazon and other third parties.
All content published on the website is compiled and edited by the editorial team of Hana Hotel Travel Company. Before publication, each piece undergoes thorough scrutiny and is approved by our Expert Review Board to ensure its quality and relevance. Sir Mark Zoch oversees the entire process and is responsible for ensuring the quality and accuracy of the content presented on the site.
Scroll to Top